Best Sheets for Crib Mattress & Baby Mattress Protectors : A Buyer’s Guide

Why Do You Need The Best Sheets For Crib Mattresses?

Cribs have a specialty mattress and the sheets that fit on your bed will not fit on your baby’s crib mattress. There are a few different sizes of crib mattresses and the sheets from one won’t fit the sheets from another. Your crib mattress has an important job to do in keeping your baby safe, comfortable and healthy. We tend to put a lot more thought into which products are right when it comes to our children and this applies to choosing the right bed sheets for crib mattress.

You don’t want your baby exposed to toxins and their soft skin is delicate and needs sheets that are equally soft. Baby’s can develop allergies too and you want to make sure your bed sheet is hypoallergenic. Baby’s aren’t born with temperature regulation so it’s very important that your sheets are the right material to keep their body at the right temperature. You should also focus on finding a bed sheet that’s going to be super easy to clean since you’re going to be busy enough doing laundry with your little one without having to worry about running to a dry cleaner to clean your baby’s sheets!

It is important to know that you do not need a flat sheet or a comforter for a crib mattress. In fact, you should not use any bedding in the crib except for the fitted mattress protector and the fitted sheet. Any additional bedding or pillows puts your kid at risk of SIDS; because babies are not strong enough to untangle themselves from loose bedding and they can easily suffocate.


How Do You Choose The Best Sheets For Crib Mattress?


Mattress Thickness

The first thing you should do when choosing the best bed sheets for your crib mattress is to measure your mattress. Crib mattresses come in two main sizes. The standard size for crib mattresses is  27 1/4″ x 57 5/8″ without exceeding 6″ deep.

There are also mini crib mattresses for portable play yards and mini cribs. These are typically 24″ x 38″ with a depth of 5″. You should have no trouble finding the right sheet to fit either one of these two sizes. It is extremely important to make sure that your baby’s crib sheet fits snuggly to the crib mattress so that there are no loose pieces of material that can cause your baby to suffocate.


Once you know the size of the sheet you’re going to need you should turn your attention to your budget. Baby’s are expensive enough without spending a fortune on bedsheets. They’re not going to be in the crib for very long so you don’t need to invest a fortune into their baby bedding. There’s a good chance that there will be several accidents on these sheets as well and you’re going to need multiple sheets so keep this in mind when determining your budget. The industry knows what parents need out of their crib sheets so they’ve made sure that there are affordable options that have everything you need to keep your baby safe and comfortable.


A special consideration with crib mattress sheets is waterproofing. I recommend that you make sure you get both a crib sheet and a waterproof mattress protector for crib. The waterproof mattress protector will help keep any midnight accidents away from the mattress so that you can just slip the bedsheet and the mattress protector off and toss them both in the wash without worrying about scrubbing your mattress.

RELATED:  Top 6 Best Sheets for Air Mattress: A Buyer's Guide

I would also recommend getting a few of both the crib sheet and the waterproof protector. This will allow you to layer two on the crib at a time like a lasagna so that if your baby has an accident in the middle of the night you can strip off one layer of bedding and still have a complete layer underneath so you don’t have to re-make the bed by the light of a nightlight.


When choosing the right crib bedding it’s essential that you take the material of the sheets into consideration. Different materials are going to have different qualities that will appeal to you. When you break it down into two main categories you’re going to have natural fibres and synthetic.

Natural fibres are known for being a little more pricey and require a little more effort to keep clean; however, they’re also softer and more durable than synthetic fibres. On the other hand, synthetic fibres are more cost-effective and are super easy to care for while being hypoallergenic.


You want hypoallergenic bedding when you’re choosing bedding for your child’s crib. Baby’s skin is super sensitive and they can develop rashes easily so look for hypoallergenic bedding and try to find bedding that doesn’t contain any chemicals or toxins.


The material you choose should also be very durable and stand the test of time.

You’re going to be washing their sheets more than you’d care to think about so make sure those sheets are going to be just as soft and the colors are going to be just as bright after 100 washes as they were when you first put them on the crib mattress. Because you’re going to be washing the sheets often you want to find sheets that you can just toss in the washer and walk away from.


Softness is going to be a big factor in determining which sheets to choose from. Your baby’s skin is soft and you only want them sleeping on the best sheets possible so the softer the sheets, the happier you and your baby will be. The breathability of the sheets also comes into play for several reasons. If your sheets allow a lot of air through them you could help reduce the risk of SIDS in your infant in case they roll over in the middle of the night and can’t breathe.


Breathability is also important for temperature regulation. Baby’s can’t regulate their own body temperatures and they need us to make sure they’re dressed appropriately. If they’re too warm you want sheets that allow a lot of air movement through them to keep their body temperature nice and cool. This will also help prevent SIDS as babies who overheat are more susceptible to it. If it’s winter or your baby’s bedroom is naturally cool I’d recommend a warmer sheet such as flannel to help keep your baby warm.

Other People Also Viewed:

Best Sheets for Crib Mattress

Best Bed Sheets For Hot Sleepers

Best Sheets For Adjustable Beds

Best Sheets With Deep Pockets

Best Sheets For Memory Foam Mattress

Sheets For RV Mattress

Recommended Products and Reviews – Crib Sheet and Mattress Protectors

If you’re pressed for time and don’t want to sort through all of the above criteria yourselves then I’ve put together a list of my personal favorites that will make it easier to choose the best bed sheet for your crib mattress. Below are sheets for both standard sized cribs and mini crib mattress. I’ve also included what I feel to be the best waterproof mattress protector on the list.

RELATED:  Top 6 Best Sheets with Deep Pockets [5 Factors To NOTE]

Best Sheets For Crib Mattress

1.American Baby Company – Sheets For Mini Crib Mattress

American Baby Crib Sheet for Toddler Mattresses[maxbutton name=”cta-or-big”  window=”new” nofollow=”true” url=”″]

This set of crib sheets from the American Baby Company is made from 100% cotton. The bedding is sized to fit a mini crib mattress or portable playpen. There are 29 pretty colors to choose from including colors for baby girls, baby boys and some nice neutral options as well. The jersey cotton in these sheets is very breathable and extremely soft for your baby’s delicate skin.

The pockets on the fitted sheet are 5″ deep and will fit a mattress up to 3″ deep with a large elastic to help hold the sheet to the mattress. These sheets do require a little bit of care when washing as they should be washed in cold water. The sheets do not shrink after washing which is an important consideration when choosing a natural fibre like cotton. This set is of great value because you get two crib sheets for the price of some single sheets.



TILLYOU Silky Soft Microfiber Crib Sheet Set[maxbutton name=”cta-or-big”  window=”new” nofollow=”true” url=”″]

If you have a standard size crib mattress then this pack of microfiber sheets is perfect for you. The microfiber is hypoallergenic, which is an important consideration when you’re choosing bedding for your baby. The sheets have been made without chemicals and the material that they’re made from has been grown without pesticides or chemicals so you can be sure that your baby’s completely safe.

They’re also very breathable to help regulate your baby’s body temperature and super soft against your baby’s delicate skin. There are four color combinations to choose from and this is a two-piece set making it an affordable option for crib bedding. These fitted sheets fit a mattress up to 8″ deep with a nice sturdy elastic to hold the sheets in place. These sheets are very easy to care for and you can also toss them in the dryer. They come with a 30-day money-back guarantee so if you’re unhappy with the sheets in any way they’ll refund your money no questions asked.


3.Burts Bees

Burts Bees Fitted Sheets for Cribbed Mattress[maxbutton name=”cta-or-big”  window=”new” nofollow=”true” url=”″]

A slightly pricier option is this set of two fitted sheets from Burts Bees. With the added price you know you’re getting added quality as these sheets are 100% organic and safe for your baby. These sheets are made from 100% cotton are are extremely soft in order to protect your baby’s sensitive skin. The cotton is very breathable to prevent your baby from sweating and it helps regulate your baby’s body temperature.

This cotton is very durable and will withstand all the washes you can throw at it without the sheet shrinking, pilling or losing its color. With this set, you have 18 color options to choose from including some nice neutral options which can sometimes be hard to find. The fitted sheets feature a thick elastic to hold the sheet securly on the cirb mattress without the sheet shifting around or bunching, which can be dangerous. The sheets also feature added fabric for under the bottom of the mattress for increased security.

RELATED:  Best Sheets for Memory Foam Mattress [8 KEY Factors]



UOMNY 100% Cotton Fitted Crib Sheets For Crib Mattress[maxbutton name=”cta-or-big”  window=”new” nofollow=”true” url=”″]

If color options are what you’re looking for in your crib bedding then these are the sheets for you! They come in a wide array of 43 colors with some really cute patterns for boys, girls and neutral. This is another two-pack of sheets so you get more bang for your buck. They are made from 100% cotton. They have 3 different sizes to choose from so look at the dimensions of your mattress and these sheets carefully to find your best match.

The fitted sheets offer 360 degree protection from slippage with a wide elastic to grip the mattress. Like the Burts Bees, these sheets are also organic and contain no pesticides or chemicals that could hurt your baby’s sensitive skin. They’re hypoallergenic and very soft. These sheets do require a bit more care washing as they need to be washed in cold water and they might bleed color a little bit the first time you wash them. If you’re up for the added care these sheets can be a great organic cotton option that will cost you less than what you’d spend on the Burts Bees sheets.


Best Waterproof Baby Mattress Protectors

1.American Baby Company

American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Quilted Crib and Toddler Protective Pad Cover[maxbutton name=”cta-or-big”  window=”new” nofollow=”true” url=”″]

A good match for the above crib sheets is this 2 pack of mattress protectors for mini cribs, also from the American Baby Company. This 2 pack of mattress protectors is made of waterproof vinyl surrounded by a top and bottom layer of polyester so your baby is comfortable.

This soft layer of polyester also helps get rid of any crinkling noises as your baby rolls around through the night. These sheets couldn’t be easier to clean, just tear them off the mattress and toss them in the wash. They can even go in your dryer. The deep pockets on this fitted sheet will fit up to a 6″ deep mattress.


2.Vesta Baby

Crib Mattress Protector[maxbutton name=”cta-or-big”  window=”new” nofollow=”true” url=”″]

To match the standard size crib sheets from Tillyou, Burts Bees and UOMNY I’d recommend these mattress protectors from Vesta Baby. There is only one mattress protector included so you might have to buy a few of these but the quality of the waterproof sheets makes it worthwhile.

These crib protectors are hypoallergenic and made with no pesticides or chemicals. They’re 100% safe for your baby. They’re easy to care for, you just toss them in the wash and you’re done. The bamboo material and the weave of the sheet make them super absorbent and you know they’ll do the job to protect your mattress from leaks. An added bonus to this sheet is that it protects against stains as well.


Other People Also Viewed:

Best Fitted Sheets For Air Mattress


Which is the Best Sheets For Baby Mattress?

Between the buying guide above and the product recommendations, I’m sure you’ll find the perfect sheets for crib mattress. You can’t go wrong with any of the above options for your little one’s crib. Happy Shopping! is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to